THE REAL VICTIMS OF ENRON

Although plenty of folks lost plenty of money in the Enron debacle, the biggest victims may have been the employees whose retirement plans were invested heavily or solely in Enron stock.

As I have argued elsewhere, a broker who fails to recommend that a customer diversify violates the NASD suitability rule and his fiduciary duty (assuming that the customer relies on the broker). The Suitability Rule, Investor Diversification, and Using Spread to Measure Risk, 54 Bus. Law. 1599 (1999). The rule is the same for trustees under the common law. And the rule should be the same for employers. To be sure, ERISA expressly imposes a fiduciary duty on plan trustees and expressly requires that the trustee diversify "so as to minimize the risk of large losses unless ... it is clearly prudent not to do so." See ERISA §404. The trouble is it is never prudent not to do so.

On the other hand, if the plan is a profit-sharing plan or ESOP, diversification makes no more sense than compensating a CEO with shares in a mutual fund. But ERISA has exceptions for such plans. The real problem is that most employees do not understand the difference between a retirement plan and a profit-sharing plan. And ERISA more or less precludes the provision of investment advice, because of worries about conflicts of interest. If employees are going to be responsible for their own retirement, they need disinterested investment advice.

The shift away from traditional defined benefit plans is inevitable if US business is to be globally competitive. So it is not surprising that business has been pushing it. (What is surprising is that business has not been pushing for national health insurance. But that is for another post.)

But there is one another change that might change things. Under the corporation laws of most (if not all states), shares reacquired by a corporation (treasury shares) lose their vote. In the absence of such a rule, the board of directors would get to vote treasury shares, and they could easily insulate the corporation from takeover by buying back a majority of shares.

There is a huge exception to this rule. Shares held in a fiduciary capacity retain their votes. See DGCL 160(c); MBCA 7.21(c). So the board (or whomever the board appoints to serve as trustee) can vote the shares. How many companies do you suppose would load up their retirement plans with their own shares but for the fact that it augments takeover defenses?

The problem is that I cannot imagine any state being so bold as to be the first to make this change. The race to the bottom is one thing, but jumping off a cliff is quite another. One hope is that the framers of the MBCA might rethink this provision and catalyze change at least in those states that tend to follow suit.

Comments

[Jordan Trunner]

Just wanted to say that you have some awesome content on your website. If it's OK I would like to use some of the information you provided on my webiste. If I link back to your website would it be OK to do so?

[ugg outlet]

Good artilce!!! You and I have common interests! You are my part of the story!

[ugg kensington]

We all live on 21st century,health is most important thing,keep our body well is good for you and me.Here we ecommend an health shoes to you.

[ugg adirondack boot]

It sounds well for this paper.

[ugg adirondack boot]

i am just a little surprising for your mind.

[Ray ban Sungalsses]

Numbers of websites and retail stores are selling this jersey display case. some websites recommended retail stores for your ease from where you can purchase this case.How To Build Jersey Display CaseTo make your own jersey display case follow these stepsFirst of all measure the width and length of jersey in fashion and order you want to display in the case.Secondly you have chosen the material for your case. This could be birch, oak, cedar orwalnat.Now you cut the wood in the desired size but make sure that the corners are mitered to build the case. There must be two sides back, top and a bottom one.

[Air Yeezys]

Such a good writing, or by I saw for the first time. I'm quite happy, you are a good writer

[Nike Air Max]

I don't know how to receive my responce. Waiting for your reply, tks!

http://www.nikeairmaxhop.com/

[Christian Louboutin]

Your article very interesting, I have introduced a lot of friends look at this article, the content of the articles there will be a lot of attractive people to appreciate, I have to thank you such an article.

[Air Yeezys]

I don't know how to receive my responce. Waiting for your reply, tks!

[Air Yeezys]

I don't know how to receive my responce. Waiting for your reply, tks!

[Nike Air Pippen]

This article is very good. I'd like it.

[Nike Air Yeezy]

Accidentally read your article, I was deeply attracted, thank you for the article.

[Nike Air Yeezy]

Accidentally read your article, I was deeply attracted, thank you for the article.

[Asics Tiger]

This article wrote too good, I don't know what to say.

[Asics Tiger]

This article wrote too good, I don't know what to say.

[MBT Sale]

Saw this article after this article, make me think big, really good.

[MBT Sale]

Saw this article after this article, make me think big, really good.

[nike free]

One hope is that the framers of the MBCA might rethink this provision and catalyze change at least in those states that tend to follow suit.

[nike free]

might rethink this provision and catalyze change at least in those states that tend to follow suit.

[Lanyard keychain]

Lanyard keychain is known as a top provider of top quality plain lanyards, heavy-duty badge reels, badge holder lanyards, Custom Printed MLB Lanyards, and personalized lanyards ID tag solution. Lanyards and Custom lanyards are simply order over the company’s web page twenty-four hours a day or by phone. Their friendly and professional personnel will reply to any or all your need. You may select from limitless NFL Lanyards color options, attachments, along with custom lanyards accessories. They've competitive prices along with well-designed application on the internet, not only they may math their competitors price but in addition suggest an extra 5% off of their competition NBA Lanyards.

[Nfl Jerseys Usa]

Nfl Jerseys Usa are determined to purchase , then you definitely will desire to finish your look at to know what to actual appearance for in fake ones.are dealing with are reputable and trusted. You must be also conscious of the conditions and problems Nfl Jerseys For Sale to executing any transaction with these suppliers.we have loads of in stock, and affordable! all those return and shipping and delivery suggestions in particular can truly be compensated considerable concern in circumstance this sort of situation Nfl Jersey Sale

[Nfl Jerseys For Sale]

Nba Jerseys.. Xiedong Chen fell to the ground, a shape. Finally, knocking the ball as hard behind, with their vacant high enough, arm strength and lack of power back stoop, Xiedong Chen realized that they do not have to protect the floor and when the Sale Nfl Jerseys and the earth to A close contact. Han Han laughing. Read a written Mudeng of all this. His joke that he actually believed it. Xiedong Chen got up slowly, his knees broken, but fortunately the red 23 not bad. Made with the ball again, just the same action, different direction The same result, but this Xiedong Chen tried to hold a hand on the floor under relief momentum without Nfl Jerseys For Sale.

[Christian Louboutin Outlet]

Sorry,i don't know how to receive my response, why?

http://www.christianlouboutindiscounts.com/

[Nike Air Jordan]

The people who get on in this world are the people who get up and look for circumstances they want , and if they cannot find them .they make them.